ROI in Design: Where to Focus Your Efforts First

When teams map out a customer experience, the instinct is often to identify the low points and fix them. Maybe onboarding seems impractical, checkout takes too long, or support flow is confusing. The hope is simple: if we remove these frustrations, customers will walk away with a better memory of the experience. 

Yet research and practices suggest otherwise. In The Power of Moments, Chip and Dan Heath argue that patching negative moments rarely produces a strong return on investment. Eliminating pain points makes the experience more functional, but not necessarily more memorable. Customers don’t often recall that something wasn’t frustrating, but they remember the standout moments that left them delighted, surprised, or empowered. 

This is where many teams miss an opportunity. Instead of focusing solely on smoothing the lows, a more impactful strategy is to amplify the highs. Positive elements carry more weight in shaping the overall perception of your product, but this is easier said than done. 

Creating high-impact, positive moments consistently is challenging. It requires understanding not just usability, but also emotion, timing, and context. What feels meaningful to users? When do they need reassurance, and when do they crave delight? Answering these questions demands an external lens that challenges assumptions and sparks new ideas. 

That’s exactly why we offer our Design Critique Lab. By stepping into your product with fresh eyes, we uncover not only where the negatives drag things down, but also where the positives could be amplified into unforgettable peaks. Instead of chasing incremental fixes, we help teams focus energy on the moments that create a lasting impact. Fixing lows keeps you competitive, but magnifying the highs helps you stand out. Our Design Critique can help you find those opportunities and turn them into an experience your customer is sure to remember. 

Learn more here. 

FAQs

What is ROI in design, and why is it important for business growth?

ROI in design (or UX ROI) measures how design decisions contribute to business outcomes like higher conversions, stronger engagement, improved retention, and lower support costs. Understanding design ROI helps organizations spend their design budget where it will have the greatest impact.

How does design improve customer experience and increase ROI?

Effective design enhances customer experience by reducing friction, supporting users at key moments, and creating positive emotional peaks in the journey. When customers feel confident and delighted, they’re more likely to stay, return, and recommend your product — all of which directly increase ROI.

What are “peak moments” in UX, and how do they affect user perception?

Peak moments are high-impact points in a user journey where customers feel supported, surprised, or especially satisfied. Research shows these emotional peaks shape how customers remember an experience and influence long-term loyalty, making them critical for maximizing the ROI of your design investments.

Should teams prioritize fixing UX pain points or designing standout moments first?

Both matter, but the highest ROI comes from a combined approach: fix the major usability blockers first, then identify opportunities to create meaningful, memorable moments. Improving these two areas together drives stronger engagement and elevates the entire customer experience.

What is a Design Critique Lab, and how can it improve product performance?

A Design Critique Lab is an expert, outside-in review of your product experience. At OCAD U CO, our design facilitators evaluate usability, emotional impact, and overall experience quality. The result is a clear set of prioritized recommendations that help teams increase customer satisfaction, conversions, and long-term product performance.

Why is an external design critique valuable for teams with internal designers?

Internal teams often have blind spots due to familiarity and competing priorities. An external design critique brings unbiased insights, fresh perspective, and expert evaluation. It helps teams spot missed opportunities, rethink assumptions, and identify design improvements with higher ROI potential.

How can companies measure the ROI of UX improvements or design critiques?

You can measure design ROI through improvements in metrics like:

• conversion rates

• onboarding completion

• customer satisfaction (CSAT)

• Net Promoter Score (NPS)

• retention and repeat use

• reduction in support tickets

Tracking these metrics before and after improvements makes it easier to quantify the impact of design on business results.

Does designing for peak moments work across different industries?

Yes — designing for peak moments is effective in SaaS, ecommerce, financial services, healthcare, education, government services, and B2B environments. Any product or service with a customer journey can benefit from strategic experience moments that drive engagement and differentiation.

When should organizations invest in a design critique or design review?

A design critique is most valuable before a major launch, when engagement is dropping, when user feedback points to frustration, or when a team needs clarity on where design efforts will have the greatest business impact. It’s also useful during strategic planning to align the roadmap around the user journey.

How does improving customer experience design create competitive advantage?

A well-designed customer experience sets a brand apart by making interactions faster, easier, and more emotionally resonant. Companies that prioritize design often see higher loyalty, stronger word-of-mouth, and better market differentiation — all key drivers of sustained competitive advantage.